Welcome

Find lakefronts, lake views, cottages, weekend get-a-ways, year-round homes, commercial property, businesses, vacant land, and more.
Plus, learn about real estate career opportunities available to you with Coldwell Banker Bainbridge Kaufman Real Estate.

About This Site
Conneaut Lake Map
Pymatuning Lake Map
All Property By List
www.realestateconneautlake.com
   Go To:  Conneaut Lake Residential Listings
   Go To:  Conneaut Lake Land Listings    Go To:  Pymatuning Lake Land Listings
   Go To:  Conneaut Lake Multi Family Listings    Go To:  Pymatuning Lake Multi Family Listings
   Go To:  Conneaut Lake Map
   Go To:  Pymatuning Lake Map


Conneaut Lake Residential Listings

MLS #: 90628.  So new, it isn't even complete. Large home with room to grow. Main floor will be complete. Upper level would make a wonderful bedroom/play area/office. Many possibilities there. Lower level has been drywalled to allow for large (18x46) Family Room.

Price:  $269,900      Total SqFt:  2543      Bedroom:  3      Bathroom:  2
Address:  12330 Dogwood Lane, Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  Pam Willis       Slideshow      E-mail Pam

MLS #: 91628 - Pending.  Perfect vacation getaway or year round home! Boat dock potential through John Harned. Beach Privileges through Harned. Large 2 car garage w/ extra storage. Fenced yard. $2,500 roof allowance from seller.

Price:  $84,900      Total SqFt:  986      Bedroom:  3      Bathroom:  2
Address:  10736 Pymatuning Ave., Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  David Schepner       Slideshow      E-mail Pam

MLS #: 91892.  120' of lake frontage on prestigious Aldina Drive. It would take very little to turn this house into a duplex, allowing you to rent one side and use the other. Perhaps a mother-in-law apartment. Becoming a rental allows you to take advantage of the tax laws making it more affordable. Realtor owned.

Price:  $619,900      Total SqFt:  3195      Bedroom:  7      Bathroom:  4
Address:  10572 Aldina Dr., Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  Gene Duffy       Slideshow      E-mail Pam

MLS #: 91893.  Newly remodeled lakefront. Livingroom firleplace, central air. New cherry kitchen cabinets, oak flooring, 2 new heat pumps, 41' carpeted sundeck, water treatment system, concrete sea wall, floating Easy Dock. Master Suites on upper and lower levels. Realtor owned.

Price:  $589,900      Total SqFt:  1601      Bedroom:  4      Bathroom:  2
Address:  10552 Aldina Dr., Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  Gene Duffy       Slideshow      E-mail Pam

MLS #: 91960.  Original carved woodwork plus open spindle staircase in entry foyer. French doors separate Living and Dining Rm. Freshly painted original hand built cabinets in kitchen. 1 very Victorian BR. Oak vanity/new drywall ceiling and walls/new vinyl in bath. Antique light fixtures. Roof 1991. 16x18 picnic deck. Surveyed. Direct TV (4/09). 2009-100Amp Circuit Breaker.

Price:  $69,900      Total SqFt:  1560      Bedroom:  4      Bathroom:  1
Address:  240 S. Second Street, Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  Cherie Jones       Slideshow      Contact Pam

MLS #: 92071.  Totally remodeled, and fully furnished, two bedroom home on the East Side of Beautiful Conneaut Lake. Fenced corner lot, sundeck and near Midway Beach. Low taxes. Seller is Realtor related.

Price:  $109,900      Total SqFt:  800      Bedroom:  2      Bathroom:  1
Address:  11967 Kammerer Ave., Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  Gene Duffy       Slideshow      E-mail Pam

MLS #: 92974.  Wall of stone surrounds this beautiful fireplace in living room, 4 bedrooms gives space for everyone, beautiful cherry kitchen cabinets. Walk to lake, join association and enjoy the beach area, waiting list for dock space. Priced to include 2 extra lots or purchase for $124,900.

Price:  $119,000      Total SqFt:  1458      Bedroom:  4      Bathroom:  1.5
Address:  12070 Choctaw Circle, Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  (Office)       Slideshow      E-mail Pam

MLS #: 92983.  Enormous home, just 200 feet from Conneaut Lake. A partial view of the water is one of the many amenities this home has to offer. Home is ready for vacation fun. Two huge living areas are perfect for lots of guests, including a pool table, kegerator and mini-fridge. Ample parking and not much grass to mow. Ready to move in!

Price:  $225,000      Total SqFt:  2160      Bedroom:  7      Bathroom:  2
Address:  11578 E First Street, Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  David Schepner       Slideshow      E-mail Pam

MLS #: 92987.  Enjoy 4 seaons at this great 3 bedroom cottage 3 blocks from Midway Beach. 2 porches, plus deck overlooking cute stream (Willow Run). Storage in attic. Livable and comfortable. Knotty pine in most rooms. Ready to move-in. Midway Beach details available upon request.

Price:  $69,900      Total SqFt:  794      Bedroom:  3      Bathroom:  1
Address:  12027 Teifer Ave. Ext., Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  David Schepner       Slideshow      E-mail Pam

MLS #: 93003.  Fantastic lake-view, year-round cottage overlooking beautiful Conneaut Lake. Tons of amenities: 2 living areas, each with a fireplace. Wet bar, spacious main living room with a stunning view of the lake. Tiled kitchen and baths, huge storage shed and much more. Updated electric and freshly painted exterior. New driveway and hot water heater. Some hardwood floors.

Price:  $325,000      Total SqFt:  1815      Bedroom:  3      Bathroom:  2.5
Address:  11461 E First Street, Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  David Schepner       Slideshow      E-mail Pam

MLS #: 93028.  "A Leap Away"! A frog with long legs could leap into Conneaut Lake from this year round ranch located in Midway Beach Allotment on the East Side of Beautiful Conneaut Lake. Features include garage, Knotty Pine walls, heated sun room facing the lake, ceiling fans in every room and all appliances. New roof in 2009. Dont miss this one.

Price:  $152,500      Total SqFt:  1252      Bedroom:  3      Bathroom:  1.5
Address:  11867 Teifer Ave., Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  Pam Willis       Slideshow      E-mail Pam

MLS #: 93029.  "Where the action is!" Walk or ride to Conneaut Lake Park from this 3 bedroom ranch which is centrally located to all the west side attractions. Extra large fenced in lot for children or pets. Cottage is not year round but heated for extended spring/summer and fall use. Low taxes and utilities.

Price:  $53,900      Total SqFt:  740      Bedroom:  3      Bathroom:  1
Address:  10589 Woodland Ave., Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  Pam Willis       Slideshow      E-mail Pam

MLS #: 93164.  Vacant and ready to move in, this 3 bedroom, 2 bath, in town home is near to mast all of your needs. Swim and boat dock at Fireman's Beach. Oversized garage. Price has been greatly reduced for a quick sale.

Price:  $49,900      Total SqFt:  1544      Bedroom:  3      Bathroom:  2
Address:  315 High St., Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  Gene Duffy       Slideshow      E-mail Pam

MLS #: 93177 - Pending.  This handsome lakefront is timeless, elegant and rich with history. A spectacular living room overlooking "The Lake" has new hardwood flooring and a gorgeous stone fireplace, rumored to be built with stones from the lake. The screened front porch allows you to see from Conneaut Lake Park to Silver Shores Restaurant- Incredible view! A stone patio (also overlooking the lake) is fantastic for a quick lunch between ski-runs or sunset beverages with friends. Spacious bedrooms with views, baths through-out, and central air make this a keeper!

Price:  $449,900      Total SqFt:  1930      Bedroom:  4      Bathroom:  4
Address:  11988 Lake Drive, Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  David Schepner       Slideshow      E-mail Pam

MLS #: 93317.  Spectactular Nantucket Cape on the east shore of Conneaut Lake with private beach and boat dock. Enjoy the warmth and consistency of the heated floors. Wonderfully open living areas with sliding glass doors to large deck overlooking lake. Private office with his and hers custom cherry desks. Quality brick and Hardy-Plank construction w/ too many extras to mention. Ceramic on main level matches the stone walkways (stone was original to 1902 house). This home exudes character. Granite kitchen countertops. Seller is PA licensed associate broker.

Price:  $795,000      Total SqFt:  2916      Bedroom:  4      Bathroom:  3
Address:  11337 Quigley Lane, Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  David Schepner       Slideshow      E-mail Pam

MLS #: 93347.  Convert back to 4 - 5 bedroom home or live in part and use rent from other to pay for mortgage. Nice location. Currently rented.

Price:  $83,900      Total SqFt:  1644      Bedroom:  4      Bathroom:  2
Address:  12347 Route 618, Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  Nancy Mangilo       Slideshow      E-mail Pam

MLS #: 93385.  Fantastic 5 bedroom, 3 full bath contemporary across the street from Beautiful Conneaut Lake. This home isn't just “new construction”, it's special. Views of the lake from many rooms and upper-level deck. Tasteful colors and elegant flooring adorn spacious living areas and highlight the eye-catching, cut-stone fireplace in living room. Custom maple kitchen with a center island and quartz counter-tops. Wine rack is lonely for a nice Malbec or Shiraz. Home warranty included. Beach and boat dock privileges. Private tour available.

Price:  $329,900      Total SqFt:  3200      Bedroom:  5      Bathroom:  3
Address:  11504 N. Shore Drive, Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  David Schepner       Slideshow      E-mail Pam

MLS #: 93438.  LITTLE BIG HOUSE. There isn't a small room in this lovely home in Hazel Park Association area. First floor Master bedroom with full bath. Plenty of closet space. Furnished and applianced including gas forced air heat and central airconditioning. Join Hazel Park Association for beach and boat dock on Beautiful Conneaut Lake. Also near several golf courses, restaurants and other activities that you can enjoy year-round!

Price:  $119,900      Total SqFt:  1380      Bedroom:  3      Bathroom:  2
Address:  12037 Edgeview Dr., Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  Pam Willis       Slideshow      E-mail Pam

MLS #: 93566.  Understated Elegance ! This handsome 1997 Victorian sitting on seven serene acres is a masterpeice of architecture and a beautiful balance with nature. Spacious rooms include: 4 beds, 4 baths, formal dining and study, 2 story family and foyer, 2 laundries, over-sized 2 car garage w/ storage above, 13 course basement and more. Every amenity you could hope for. Recessed lighting throughout, pocket doors, leaded-glass entry, Custom Maple kitchen, extraordinary chandelier in foyer. Stunning view of Oakland Beach Golf Course ! Survey on file.

Price:  $518,600      Total SqFt:  4576      Bedroom:  4      Bathroom:  4
Address:  12058 Hubbard Road, Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  David Schepner       Slideshow      E-mail Pam

MLS #: 93568.  Impeccably maintained 3 bed, 2 bath in a great location. Nice upgrades like ceramic tile in kitchen and new storm doors. All appliances stay, 57 Chevy does not. Current owners have added a custom shed, shrubs, trees, a 2 car parking addition. House is bright, cheery, and ready to move in.

Price:  $124,900      Total SqFt:  1484      Bedroom:  3      Bathroom:  1
Address:  10937 Griggs, Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  David Schepner       Slideshow      E-mail Pam

MLS #: 93665.  Wonderful, well amintained 3 bedroom, bath and a half home/cottage near Conneaut Lake. Spend your days golfing, waterskiing, boating and swimming. Enjoy evenings relaxing on your covered deck. Large enclosed porch for gatherings of all kinds. New roof in '07. New block foundation in '05. Retaining wall rebuilt in 2010. Don't forget to join Midway Beach Association and enjoy all of the benefits of Conneaut Lake.

Price:  $79,900      Total SqFt:  792      Bedroom:  3      Bathroom:  2
Address:  12019 Crafton Ave., Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  Pam Willis       Slideshow      E-mail Pam

MLS #: 93678.  Perfect Midway Beach year-round cottage. Entertain friends or share private getaway all year long with this 3 bed, 2 bath cape cod. Fireplace, hard wood floors and Florida room make this property pop. Great built-ins in dining room. Spacious back yard, perfect for picnics or sports. 2nd floor loft bedroom and bath will accomodate all of your friends. Full basement for beach toys and other storage.

Price:  $99,500      Total SqFt:  1325      Bedroom:  3      Bathroom:  2
Address:  12080 Midway Drive, Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  David Schepner       Slideshow      E-mail Pam

MLS #: 93751.  Better then new, hardly lived in, mostly on week ends. 3 bedroom and neutral through out the home. Eat in kitchen, large utility room and sits in among the trees for a very private feeling. Approximately 3.5 acres of land which runs down to other side of the stream into the park area. Great for family reunions, picnics and playing ball. Your going to love what you see.

Price:  $129,000      Total SqFt:  1120      Bedroom:  3      Bathroom:  2
Address:  12186 McCarthy Rd., Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  (Office)       Slideshow      E-mail Pam

MLS #: 93787.  Lauderdale Association 3BR, 2BA home with dock. Purchase this furnished 2003 home and enjoy boating and fishing on Beautiful Conneaut Lake. Sellers have already invested in the new boat docks in Lauderdale. Join the Association for sunny days on the beach and let the fun begin. There is a second lot available under MLS # 93786

Price:  $99,000      Total SqFt:  960      Bedroom:  3      Bathroom:  2
Address:  11397 Crestwood, Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  Pam Willis       Slideshow      E-mail Pam

MLS #: 93835.  Two cottages for the price of one !! Front 9 has 3 bedrooms, w/ deck and enclosed front porch. Back 9 has 2 bedrooms and enclosed porch. Both have fully equipped kitchens. Both come fully furnished. Buyer MUST honor rentals. Great Midway Beach location. 2nd block up from beach. Priced to sell.

Price:  $79,700      Total SqFt:  1421      Bedroom:  5      Bathroom:  2
Address:  12022 Midway Drive, Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  David Schepner       Slideshow      E-mail Pam

MLS #: 93847.  Put this one "High on the List". Four bedroom, year round, home with detached 2 car garage, located on "High" Street in Conneaut Lake Borough. Walk to your shopping needs. Swim and boat from Fireman's Beach. A great corner location.

Price:  $69,900      Total SqFt:  1568      Bedroom:  4      Bathroom:  2
Address:  480 High St., Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  Pam Willis      E-mail Pam

MLS #: 93884.  Come and see this newer "One of a kind" home for summer fun and year round living. The home features 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths (jacuzzi in 1), central air, open floor plan with cathedral ceilings and windows galore to bring in the sunshine. The gas fireplace in the Living Room will keep you cozy on chilly evenings. Wrap around deck, peaceful back yard, quiet street. Lake access for picnics and swimming as a member ($25 per year) of Konneyaut Knolls Assn. Good rental history.

Price:  $154,900      Total SqFt:  1404      Bedroom:  3      Bathroom:  2
Address:  10508 Mohawk Road, Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  Ellen Klinginsmith       Slideshow      E-mail Pam

MLS #: 93898.  Cute and cozy on cul de sac street. Screened porch 12 x 14, not far from Midway beach and boat docks, close to Oakland Beach Golf course. Newer stove and refrigerator. 2 beds, living room furniture, kitchen table and chairs plus porch furniture included. Property in rear goes approximately to top of hill. A tiny bit of TLC will make this a perfect vacation spot.

Price:  $56,500      Total SqFt:  672      Bedroom:  3      Bathroom:  2
Address:  12130 Teifer St. Ext., Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  (Office)       Slideshow      E-mail Pam

MLS #: 93930.  Can't beat the price. With a little work, you can make this 4 bedroom home a year round residence or cottage. Comes furnished. A very short distance to Conneaut Lake Park. Some new windowns are installed and the rest are still in the boxes just waiting for someone to put them in.

Price:  $39,900      Total SqFt:  975      Bedroom:  4      Bathroom:  1
Address:  10362 Ester St., Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  Pam Willis       Slideshow      E-mail Pam

MLS #: 93940.  This beautiful, extensively remodeled two story home sits on 20+ acres with 2272 sq.ft. of living space. Some of the many amenities include two bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, a two car attached garage and a metal pole building. The circular drive makes entry and exit easy.

Price:  $180,000      Total SqFt:  2272      Bedroom:  2      Bathroom:  1.5
Address:  13304 Harmonsburg Rd., Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  Judy Weaver       Slideshow      Contact Pam

MLS #: 93951.  Super summer getaway or year-round home ! Beautiful oak cathedral ceiling in family room, kitchen and dining areas. Well equipped kitchen with huge center island will be the hub of entertaining. Side porch with view of Conneaut Lake. About 100 feet from Huidekoper Bay Park Assoc. and 300 feet from water's edge. Sale includes boat dock . Great open floor plan.

Price:  $149,900      Total SqFt:  1227      Bedroom:  3      Bathroom:  1.5
Address:  11358 Lakeshore Drive, Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  David Schepner       Slideshow      Contact Pam

MLS #: 93989 - Pending.  Charming cottage with fireplace and great yard. One block from Shady Beach and beautiful Conneaut Lake. Hardwood flooring in bedrooms and under carpet in living room. Relatively new hot water heater. Tons of potential. Peacefull summer getaway or you could winterize it and use year-round.

Price:  $59,900      Total SqFt:  708      Bedroom:  2      Bathroom:  1
Address:  11285 Center St., Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  David Schepner       Slideshow      E-mail Pam

MLS #: 93998.  Updated home on a lovely street near school, shopping and dining. New roof. Newly painted. Remodeled bath. Knotty Pine ceiling in living room and vaulted Knotty Pine ceiling in kitchen. Huge stone fireplace. Dock a boat and swim at Fireman's Beach. Don't miss this wonderful buy.

Price:  $77,500      Total SqFt:  1040      Bedroom:  2      Bathroom:  1
Address:  270 Maple St., Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  Pam Willis       Slideshow      E-mail Pam

MLS #: 94023.  Super summer package: 2 lots with 3 bedroom, ready to move in home and detached, oversized 2 car garage, with bonus space. If you are looking for a summer getaway or year-round place to retire in, this is it. Package includes 1 boat dock space in Lauderdale Assoc. (will require yearly membership). Beach privleges with Lauderdale membership.

Price:  $159,900      Total SqFt:  1040      Bedroom:  3      Bathroom:  1
Address:  11376 Crestwood, Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  David Schepner       Slideshow      E-mail Pam

MLS #: 94024.  Exceptional home or enchanting cottage....you choose. Extraordianry home includes see-thru fireplace in family and living rooms, great yard and a dock in the newly renovated area of Lauderdale Association. This year-rounder wont last long.......

Price:  $109,900      Total SqFt:  1196      Bedroom:  2      Bathroom:  1
Address:  11386 Crestwood Ave., Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  Pam Willis       Slideshow      E-mail Pam

MLS #: 94026.  Boat from your personal dock space, swim at the Association beach, entertain in spacious livingroom/diningroom areas, cozy up to the fireplace(with heatalator), snack at the breakfast bar, kick back in the 3-season room or relax in the hot tub. Impecably-maintained with much new flooring, this 4 bedroom, air-conditioned home is a cook's delight with spacious EIK. Located a mere 150 yards from LAKE. Most furniture(which is only 2/3 years old) can be negotiated.

Price:  $229.985      Total SqFt:  2030      Bedroom:  4      Bathroom:  3
Address:  10863 Cullum Street, Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  Ed Beighey       Slideshow      E-mail Pam

MLS #: 94035.  Kozy Korner Cottage! This 3 bedroom cottage is currently used as a summer weekly rental. Sleeps 8 and features a complete kitchen, appliances, large living / dining area with vaulted ceilings, screened porch and much more. Join Midway Beach Association and enjoy your summers on Beautiful Conneaut Lake.

Price:  $57,500      Total SqFt:  720      Bedroom:  3      Bathroom:  1
Address:  11989 Teifer Ave., Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  Pam Willis       Slideshow      E-mail Pam

MLS #: 94039.  A Midway Beach Classic! This year-rounder has been in the same family for 30 years. Not only is this charming bungalow comfortable with central air and cozy with fireplace, but it is functional with new furnace and new roof! Complete with front porch swing. Beach privileges for $85/yr. Lower level bath a huge plus when you have company! Off-street parking and just enough lawn to keep the kids and pets busy, but not too much that you have to spend an entire day mowing. You are here to have fun. Ready to move in!

Price:  $99,900      Total SqFt:  1008      Bedroom:  2      Bathroom:  2
Address:  11949 Midway Drive, Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  David Schepner       Slideshow      E-mail Pam

MLS #: 94055.  High-quality furniture makes for ready-to-move-in and begin-immediate-enjoyment status for this newer home. Its nicely decorated interior is enhanced by natural light emanating from skylights in the kitchen and master bath. Jump immediately into the vacation mode, for we are less than one block to the Lake and your own boat dock (best suited for a pontoon boat) and the Association's beach for swimming/sunbathing. This gently-used home, which is situated in a quiet neighborhood, will provide pleasure for years to come.

Price:  $149,900      Total SqFt:  1232      Bedroom:  3      Bathroom:  2
Address:  10766 Sargeant Street, Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  Ed Beighey       Slideshow      E-mail Pam

MLS #: 94056.  Put a little “LAKE” in your life. Year round home or seasonal retreat. Join Shady Beach Association to access the lake and the association grass land dock and swimming area. Home has delightful Sun Room, patio for outdoor living and dining, shed for storage. Gas, forced air heat, wood burning fireplace to take the chill off chilly evenings. Window A/C, ceiling fans. New roof in 2007. Mostly furnished, except for Dining Room furniture and personal items.

Price:  $99,999      Total SqFt:  2203      Bedroom:  4      Bathroom:  2
Address:  11135 Center Street, Conneaut Lake
Listing Agent:  Ellen Klinginsmith       Slideshow      E-mail Pam